Podcast · Leadership & Pastors · January 17, 2023
013: Set Up Volunteers to Succeed in Your Small Church | Volunteer Series Part 4
Join me in learning how to create a culture where volunteers actually want to serve, and where people feel loved, honored, and supported.
This episode is all about setting up volunteers for success in small church ministry.
Sadly, that’s the opposite of what most people experience. Instead of setting up volunteers for success, we too often set up volunteers for frustration, failure, or feeling trapped - sometimes we even set them on a path to be used and used up.
Join me in learning how to create a culture where people actually want to serve, and where people feel loved, honored, and supported.
This episode is all about simple, doable steps that lead to refreshing small church ministry and a volunteer culture where people aren’t just stepping in to fill a role, but joining in a greater mission to make an impact.
Listen in to hear …
- The key to developing passionate ministry partners instead of reluctant volunteers
- Why agreeing on a job description isn’t just necessary but motivating & empowering too
- A 4-step involvement process to yield more consistent results and confidence
- How to help your volunteers go from feeling used to being supported & cared for
Resources Mentioned
Join the Everyday Influence
Check out our upcoming events
Join our free Facebook Community
Subscribe & Review
If you loved this episode, please take a moment to subscribe and leave a review on Apple Podcasts! Your support helps us reach more people—just like you—in small churches who need to hear this.
🎙 Thanks for tuning in to Small Church Ministry Podcast! See you next week!
Listen On
TranscriptEpisode 013: Set Up Volunteers to Succeed in Your Small Church | Volunteer Series Part 4Intro 0:01
Hey, this is Laurie Graham. Welcome to The Small Church Ministry Podcast.
Laurie Graham 0:15
Hey, and welcome back, we are headed into part four of our series on volunteers. If you just found our podcast, please make sure to loop back so you can soak in the full learning of this entire series. If you're like me, you could probably use a quick review, even if you've been listening since day one.
So this episode is all about setting up volunteers to succeed. If you didn't hear the last few sessions, you may be tempted to think this episode is a great place to start, because the topic of this episode is where most of us start our journey with volunteers. It's also where most of us started our journey as volunteers. Don't fall into that trap, you're going to want to start with the first two steps we talked about, otherwise, it's the biggest mistake ever.
You'll be continuing the pattern that most small churches have of asking the same people to serve over and over again, burning out the volunteers you have, being frustrated by seeming lack of commitment and lack of support from others in your church, and so much more. If you don't start at the beginning, you're not going to have enough volunteers on a consistent basis. You will continue the cycle of recruiting volunteers, losing volunteers, and looking for more volunteers over and over again.
If you're ready to quit all that and find a new way of working with volunteers that saves you time and stress in the long run, then stick with me. Practice all four I’s that we're covering in the series on volunteers and you'll find some greener grasses. When I say practice the four I’s, it really is practice. You're not going to be great at it the first time you sit down to identify volunteers, you'll come up with lots of blanks. The first time you invite somebody just to come and see your ministry area, it might feel awkward. Just like riding a bike, or maybe learning to drive a stick shift car, which took me a little longer than some, after some practice, it's just gonna click, and it'll become a beautiful habit and a natural outflowing of who you are, and how you do ministry.
Laurie Graham 2:13
In all the small church training I do, I take the principles of how God created our brains to think, our hearts to feel, our spirits to awaken, our need for community, interdependence, having our identity, securing Christ apart from our works and all that we do. All these principles and more, you're going to find woven into practical strategies that work in small churches. In the area of volunteers, instead of getting people to do stuff for you, we're talking about stirring hearts to do what God has already put in them to do. We're inviting people into a God-ordained place of belonging and significance. We're helping others find fulfillment, friends, hope, purpose, and so much more.
Doesn't that sound tons better than recruiting volunteers? Yuck, who wants to do that? So, don't do it. Just remember, volunteers don't exist to do ministry. They are our ministry. What we're doing is we are learning to love people better, to treat them with gentleness, compassion, and grace while we're inviting them into a really cool mission of joining the Almighty God, where He's already working in our churches and in our communities. Is that not amazing? That we get to partner with the most high God?
Let me back up. I guess I got a bit excited there. I hope you can tell that I believe what I'm sharing with you. I have seen God use it, and it's changed my life, the lives of other ministry leaders and volunteers, and it's changed how I do ministry. You with me? Do you want that too? I hope so. Let's jump in.
Laurie Graham 3:54
In our progression through the four I’s of volunteering, we started with the first I: identify. Please don't miss this, we need to be looking at the 80% who are not already involved, before we look to the 20% who are active in serving.
The second I: invite. If you remember, that's all about the grocery store samples before buying. This is where we invite people to come and see, not to volunteer, but just to come and see what we do. It's kind of like a taste and see. Again, if you missed episode 12, go back and catch it because you need that strategy in your tool belt. Inviting people to come and see has so many benefits and really is key in helping people get in the right places from the start.
I remember learning about Apple, you know the company, in a college business management class I took way back before Apple was the giant it is today. I believe when we were talking in class about when Apple was improving the very first Macintosh computer. It must have been in the 80s I imagine. My professor shared that during the interview process for a new employee, they gathered around the computer and the computer was covered up like beneath a protective cloth or something. What they did as part of this interview process is they would sit a potential new employee down in front of the veiled computer. As they lift the cover off, they would watch to see if his or her eyes lit up. Did their eyes light up? That's what they were watching for. I have never forgotten that story.
This is what I do in ministry, this is the come and see, when I would tell somebody about my ideas for a creative team, I wanted to see if they were excited if their eyes lit up. When I look for team members for The Creative Little Church, I watched for this too. Do their eyes light up when we talk about small churches, when we talk about volunteers being our friends? It really is a beautiful piece of the puzzle when you're looking for volunteers and ministry partners.
Laurie Graham 5:51
That can help a lot in that Invite step, that second I; the come and see. Maybe somebody is hesitant to work with kids, but when they come and see, you see a spark in their eyes. Maybe somebody has never sung with a microphone, and they're not confident at all, but you can see their passion when they close their eyes in joyful worship. Maybe somebody is saying with their words, that they're too busy to help with hospitality, but you notice at church, they totally light up as they greet new people on Sunday mornings. Naturally, they love it, and they're drawn to it.
Keep those things in mind in all the steps. We are not recruiting volunteers, we are loving people, and we are helping them find their significant fit in the Body of Christ in God's family. How incredibly cool is that? What a calling we have. Identify and invite those are the first two eyes on today's topic; the third I is: Involve.
We're going to be talking about involving volunteers, you've identified them, you've invited them to taste and see, all the lights look green, so we're gonna move on to involve them. This episode is titled Set up Volunteers to Succeed in Your Small Church. Sadly, usually, the opposite of that is what most of us have experienced, you've probably been there. We definitely may feel set up all right, but the word success might not follow that phrase.
Instead, lots of us and other volunteers have felt set up for frustration, set up to fail, set up with no support, maybe even set up for an eternal commitment that they don't ever remember agreeing to. So instead of feeling like somebody has their back, or that they have help, if it's needed, they may feel abandoned, and equipped, insecure, not confident. We're not really sure what we're supposed to be doing, if we're doing it right, if we're allowed to do it differently. Or sometimes we're not even sure how to get out of it. I want to tell you, it doesn't have to be this way.
Laurie Graham 8:02
If you have experienced those things firsthand, in your own volunteer past, or maybe you are even right now, I want to apologize on behalf of church people everywhere. I am so sorry. It should not be this way, it is not God's design. I've been there too. Being set up to fail can cause us not to want to serve ever again. It can strain relationships. Maybe most sadly, we often unintentionally continue the pattern, we extend it to others as we move into leadership.
Maybe we tweak it a little because we want to do better. We've decided we're going to be kinder than what we experienced or maybe more supportive. But you cannot give what you don't have. You can't teach what you've never learned. Grace to you and me and all of us on the journey as we commit to doing this better.
In the next few episodes, you notice some twangs of feeling guilty, how you've set up volunteers to fail, maybe been part of damaging relationships, even their relationship to the church. Maybe you see where you lack. If you notice these things in yourself, do not spin into any type of condemnation, because that is not from God at all. We've all been there. It's human. I've been there, I still go there. Sometimes I forget to be clear about an expectation, or I get wrapped up in my own busyness, and out of desperation, I grab some willing hands to help, and it's not good for them. It wasn't the right spot or the right timing. Maybe I just failed as a leader.
For example, last year, we invited some content creators to write blog posts for The Creative Little Church website. I was so excited and I totally failed. I failed in supporting them, in encouraging them, and giving them clear guidelines, and even in giving them helpful feedback. I just want to thank God and truly thank God this year, my sister took it over and she has become an amazing leader of our content team. She supports them and trains them. She's running systems that's making everything lighter and beautiful, less stress, more effective ministry, better relationships. It is so amazing people growing in skill and influence and having a great time doing it. That is how it should be. If you have messed up, me too. That's why we practice and that's why there's grace, so all Grace to you and me as we journey into setting up volunteers to succeed.
Laurie Graham 10:40
The biggest key in involving volunteers, remember, this is the third I: involve, is setting them up for success from the very beginning. Again, if you've walked through the first two I’s, you identified volunteers from the 80%, you invited someone to come and see, all the lights look green and go and you're excited; this is how to involve them.
Set up your potential lifelong ministry partners for success with three main things. Number one, write a great job description. Number two, get their agreement. Number three, utilize this four-step process to involve them. Let's just unpack this.
Number one, write a great job description. Don't get caught up in thinking this job description is going to look like something you had at work 10 years ago in corporate America, it does not have to be formal, long, or intimidating. If you listen to the podcast episode number nine all about job descriptions, you'll get the gist that this can be very simple, casual, fun, and motivating. It might just be a few sentences, followed by a couple bullet points. A great job description should contain a start and end date. At the end date, there should be a time to evaluate, to give feedback, and to give clear permission for someone to leave a ministry.
The second thing job descriptions should contain clear points. How do they know if they've done a good job? The environment is so warm and inclusive that nobody wants to leave at the end, or meetings are so motivated, that everyone is clear on what action item gets taken, and follow through is always communicated. Maybe it's so specific that it says have three individual conversations to get to know somebody's needs or dreams for the future. Also, a good job description should contain steps on how to ask for help, or support, or contingency plans, like “What do I do if I can't make it?” These are all about clear lines of communication, support, and accountability. This is so important when setting up volunteers to succeed.
Laurie Graham 12:47
I'll give you a quick example of why: this happens to everyone at some time to another, they can't come, they can't make it, life happens. What happens at church is we get so upset when somebody calls off, or the nursery isn't staffed, or so–and–so didn't bring the food they committed to bring to the men's event. Here's the question: what are they supposed to do if they're sick? If they can't show up to teach? If they have a family emergency? We haven't communicated what to do, what the backup plan is. How can they get support? We're actually setting them up to fail. Make sure that's in the job description. Number one, starting them with a written job description. Don't forget to include start and end dates, bullet points of results to be achieved, and contingency plans for support and accountability.
As I mentioned in these three things, to set up volunteers to succeed, not only do you need to provide them with a motivating written job description, but number two, they need to agree to it. They need to agree to the goal. They need to know what they're committing to, whether that happens in a conversation in checkboxes or a covenant to sign. An agreement includes a clear yes, like “I want to do this. I'm saying yes on purpose. I know what I'm saying yes to.”
Do you realize how many times job descriptions are not agreed upon? In church ministry, it's almost the norm. If people do have a job description, honestly, a lot of times they have no idea the actual results that anyone's counting on. No one's agreed to the goals. People are not on the same page. We think “I'm willing, I can help or they're willing, let's get them going,” but everyone is doing their own thing. It's not right. It doesn't set people up for support, for team relationships, or for success.
We follow this process of job descriptions in The Creative Little Church with our conference volunteers, our moderators, our speakers are coordinators. This is what you're agreeing to. We ask them “Are you up for it” ahead of time. The moderators know the date that the required training session is. They know they need to show up a few minutes before they're actually on. They know every step, they check off individual boxes for each thing so there's no surprises, and they love it. You can't have an environment of growth or accountability if no one has agreed on the goals or the results.
Laurie Graham 15:18
In addition to having a job description and getting agreement to the job description, here's the third step. Follow this four-step process to get them involved. Remember, we are changing the cycle of throw them in, let them figure it out, and watch them burn out. This is what we need to do instead, set up volunteers for success by following this four-step involvement process. The first step is: you watch, I do. The second step is: we do it together. The third step: you do I watch. The fourth step is: you do. We're going to cover these four steps a few other times in the podcast. If you are driving, you do not need to stop the car to write them down, I promise we're going to loop back, and before the end of the podcast, even if you're just listening, you're going to get it. So, these are the four steps to do before you let them fly in ministry.
This might not be new information to you, but most people who even know this process, do not practice it regularly. We're too busy, or we feel too desperate. We need something now, we grab volunteers and let them figure it out. Stop it. No. Never do that again. It is not how Jesus operated and we don't have to operate like that either. If you want ministry partners who are committed to the vision. If you want people to stick with you for the long haul. If you want people to love serving at church, and if you want to experience a new way of leading volunteers, that's less stressful and more effective. Here it is. You watch, I do, then we do it together, then you do I watch, and then you do.
So this is what it looks like. Let's give an example: I am recruiting somebody to take over making social media graphics for the church Facebook page or something like that. Here we go. You watch, I do: Come and watch me make and schedule social media graphics. After you watch, I ask; “what did you think? What did you like? What do you need to learn? Do you have ideas on how you might do it differently?” Have a conversation.
Laurie Graham 17:37
The next step, we do it together: Cool. Let's make graphics together. You start, I'll give input, we'll tweak, we'll figure it out, and I'll help. After we do it together, you're going to ask again, “What do you think? What did you like? What do you need to learn? Any ideas on how you might do it differently? Are you ready to do it by yourself?”
If all the lights look green, we move on to the third step: you do and I watch. “Awesome, go for it, you do it. I'll give you feedback at the end.” Afterwards, you're going to ask them first. “What did you think? What did you like? What do you think you did really well? What would you do differently next time? Is there anything you'd like to learn new skills? How can I support you more?” Please hear that, when you do and I watch, I don't come back and tell you everything you did wrong. If you've been there, you know to avoid that. You don't have to. Ask them what they did good; what they’d do different next time, how can I support you, and only give your feedback if it's really needed. If they can't come up with one thing to change, then you can talk, otherwise, let them learn.
Okay, final step. After you do, I watch, is: you do. This is when you are ready to fly, go for it, you do it. You do it on your own. We'll touch base next week or at a monthly training or quarterly trainings. Whatever you have set up, but you're going to keep in check you're going to keep in communication. Whenever you do meet up, you're going to ask similar questions that you've asked all along. “How's it going? What's your favorite part? What do you want to improve? How can I support you better?” That's it. That's the four-step process. Simple, right? You watch, I do, then we do together, then you do I watch, and then you do. So what do you think? It is totally simple, but it does take time and intentionality.
Let me answer a few questions you might have because these are the frequent questions I get when I've taught this process in the past. Somebody invariably asks this: “So wait a minute, it takes four weeks to go through this process? Like, I don't have that kind of time. We need a nursery worker now.” So my answer to that is: no, it doesn’t just take four weeks, it could take a lot longer.
Laurie Graham 20:03
So you watch, I do, we do together, you do I watch, and you do. Those are the four steps. It doesn't always happen one step each day, it could actually take a period of months, or it could happen super fast. This depends on people's confidence, their skill, their ability, their motivation, their time availability, or even what emotional season they're in. Because let's face it, sometimes I need more hand holding, I need someone in my corner, building my confidence and encouraging me. Other times I'm like raring to go. This is human.
In the example on social media graphics I gave, the first three steps could actually happen in the same sit down. If you have someone who's done this before, they know how to use Canva, whatever it is, it could happen like this: “Watch me make some graphics. What do you think?” “Cool. Let's make some together.” Cool. What do you think?” “All right, you make some, let me just watch.” I asked for feedback, give you mine. And then “Hey, go for it. You do it.” Do you see how it works? It's not about the time, it's about the process.
To involve somebody in Sunday school, though. Adult or children's Sunday school, maybe it does take one week for each step. Maybe it's longer, maybe you can combine steps. Again, the timing isn't the key. The process is the key. You watch, I do. We do together. Third step: you do, I watch. Next step: you do. But in every step, there is conversation, communication, affirmation, feedback, questions, and more.
This process speaks to your value and your care of others. It also speaks to how much you value the ministry you represent. For the people you're serving, it speaks this; I see you. I care about your success. I have time for you. For the ministry, it speaks; I value this ministry, and I value your contribution to this ministry.
Laurie Graham 22:08
The other question I usually get is: “What if I don't have time for this process? Like I said before, I need a volunteer. Now we are desperate. If we don't get a nursery worker or whatever, fill in the blank, we're going to shut down this ministry.” So here's my answer. In all gentleness, and kindness, and empathy, I just want to say, if you don't have time for this process, to set somebody up to succeed, I encourage you to pray about if you should even be doing the ministry you're trying to do.
You see we get way ahead of ourselves running programs, and we damage people in the process, our desperation, our rush, it sets people up to fail. Then we wonder why volunteers aren't committed, aren't stepping up, or why they retire from ministry; because they've been there and done that. If volunteers aren't being cared for, feeling valued or respected, this is what happens, and it's totally understandable.
It doesn't seem very Jesus-like to me, to throw people to the wolves, or even to represent our ministry area as the wolves, a place where people are used or beaten up or feel like failures. So let's do it better. Get clear on what you need and what you want to see. This becomes the motivating, result-oriented job description. That's the first thing.
Secondly, get their agreement on the vision of that position, their agreement to the job description, and third, go through the four-step involvement process. You watch while I do it. Next, we do it together. Next, you do it while I watch. And fourthly, you do it. So that process helps give people ownership, autonomy. They're involved in evaluating and growth. Did you see that in every step of the process when we have a conversation? You're asking, What do you think? What would you change? You're building their competence and including them.
Laurie Graham 24:18
Can you see how volunteers would be different? If we followed these three steps consistently? Can you see how your volunteer culture would change with job descriptions that they agree to and the involvement process? How you would grow as a leader too. How God might be glorified as we care for volunteers, instead of using them? So what do you think? Are you ready to try it?
In next week's episode, we'll be talking about investing in your volunteers, developing a culture that creates longevity and ministry and connections that go way beyond the surface as we journey together, and knowing loving and following Christ in community, just as God designed it. We were never meant to walk this journey alone.
If you've been feeling alone in your small church, as so many people do, you don't have to feel like that anymore. If you're seeking some deeper training than we can cover in a podcast, please check out The Small Church Academy, where we take all these principles, break them down into actionable bite-sized steps together with individual feedback and support along the way, all in a focused community for learning. Can you imagine not just hearing a 30-minute podcast, but having your individual questions answered, personalized feedback, and a group of people joining you in the journey? That's what we do in The Small Church Academy.
Laurie Graham 26:01
Thank you to the person who left this review for me on Apple podcast. They said this: “Over the last couple years, I've been a subscriber to The Creative Little Church emails, and participated in conferences put on by Laurie and her team. After listening to this podcast, I have no doubt that what will be offered will be just as helpful as what I've seen and utilized from this group already. Thanks, Laurie, for seeing a need and moving ahead with it.”
That review came from Bap121970, so thank you for being such an encouragement to me because we really are in this together. Please take a minute to leave a review for this podcast. It really does help others find us and get the word out to small churches. And until next week, keep looking to the hope we all have in Jesus and be a light.