Sign in
← All episodes

Podcast · Leadership & Pastors · January 17, 2023

017: 3 Quick Wins Plus 2 Long-Term Strategies To Get More Volunteers In Children’s Ministry

Children’s ministry is a handful. Listen to this episode to learn a few unexpected quick wins to add a few more volunteers to your roster.

If you’re looking for more volunteers for your children’s ministry, you aren’t alone.

Children’s ministry takes many hands, even if you have only a handful of kiddos. An additional challenge facing staffing in small churches is the inconsistent number of children and the mixed-age factor.

One week could require a fully-staffed nursery and an extra volunteer in Sunday school, while in another week you find yourself fully staffed, but no kids show up.

It seems impossible to predict who you’ll need and when and difficult to recruit staff when the needs vary not only by the season but by the week with little predictability.

Join me in this episode to learn …

  • A few unexpected quick wins to add a few more volunteers to your roster
  • Some long-term strategies to work toward building a committed team for the future
  • Why taking better care of your current volunteers needs to move up on your priority list
  • One common (but often overlooked) reason your recruiting methods might not be working

And if you just read that description, and you’re thinking, “Team? I wish! It’s just me!” … don’t worry, I get it. There’s plenty of gold in this episode for you too!

Again, you’re not alone. Tons of small churches are just like yours, with one or two people holding down the fort. Hang with me to find a better way.

Links Mentioned:

The Runner and The Sailboat: https://smallchurchministry.com/women-in-ministry/

The Small Church Academy: Now Everyday Influence

Get Your FREE Ticket To The Small Church Kidmin + Youth Ministry Conference: https://smallchurchsummits.com/kidmin2022

Join our free Facebook Community

Check out our upcoming events

Subscribe & Review

If you loved this episode, please take a moment to subscribe and leave a review on Apple Podcasts! Your support helps us reach more people—just like you—in small churches who need to hear this.

🎙 Thanks for tuning in to Small Church Ministry Podcast! See you next week!

Listen On

TranscriptEpisode 017: 3 Quick Wins Plus 2 Long-Term Strategies To Get More Volunteers In Children’s Ministry

Intro
0:01
Hey, this is Laurie Graham. Welcome to The Small Church Ministry Podcast.

Laurie Graham 0:15
Hey, first off, I just got to start by saying thank you. Thank you for serving in your small church, the world just needs more people like you. If you're thinking, I don't know you too well, well, I think I know enough, because I know you're taking time to listen to a podcast about small church ministry. Who does that? A person who cares about their small church and somebody who wants to make a difference, somebody who wants to do better, learn more and be healthier too. So truly, the world needs more people like you.

Maybe you're looking for a better way because you're frustrated or on the edge of burnout. Maybe you're totally happy and fully aware that God is at work in your small church right where you are and you just want to do better. Find new ways of meeting needs or growing God's church the way He has in mind. For whatever reason, you're listening, I'm super grateful you're here. I really do mean it. The world needs more people like you.

Actually speaking of why you might be listening today, I have to share a little laugh with you. Last week, a pastor from Saskatchewan, Canada joined our Facebook community. When new members join, I always ask people how they found us because I think it's so cool to see people finding us through Pinterest or through our conferences, or just searching through Google or being invited by their friends.

Anyway, this pastor shared that he actually found us by accident. He said he was searching for a different podcast on Spotify, and clicked this one by mistake. Apparently, he liked it because he not only kept listening, but he also joined our Facebook community too. So you gotta love how God works, right? So even if you think you're here listening by accident, I'm still glad you're here.

Laurie Graham 1:47
Let's get into our topic for today, quick wins and long term strategies for finding more volunteers in children's ministry. Because of our upcoming conference, I've been taking a little time on the podcast this month just to focus more on children's ministry. While today's topic is totally focused on children's ministry, all of the underlying principles hold true in almost every area of ministry too because what we're talking about is volunteers.

Small churches are powered by volunteers. Volunteers make up the leadership behind the scenes, in front of the scenes like onstage and everything. Small churches would not exist without volunteers. If you wear a different hat in your church, other than children's ministry, and if you're like most of us, you probably wear lots of different hats. Feel free to swap out the illustrations in the stories I share with your own ministry area. Whether it's creative arts, women's ministry, Men's Ministry, admin and planning or whatever, you'll find all the principles are totally fitting, as I said, for different ministry areas.

Also, if you're listening right now, and you get paid by your church, that is awesome. If you are a volunteer who's serving with no pay, and no title, you are also among friends, because that's how most small churches operate. Whether you're the only one currently serving in your ministry area, or you've got a few helpers, or maybe you have a whole team of volunteers, I have never met a person in a small church who said, “Oh, we got plenty of volunteers. Nope, don't need more of those.” Like, can you imagine that? Yeah, that has been said by no one ever.

If you're in a church of 200, I've got some great principles for you. If you're in a church of 20, I've got you covered too. Children's ministry takes many hands, even if you only have a handful of kiddos. If you're looking for more volunteers in your children's ministry area, you are not alone. One other challenge that I'll mention specific to staffing children's ministry in small churches, is the inconsistent number of kids, along with the mixed age factor. Large churches have more stability and predictability in their numbers. Because having an extra family visit with four kids doesn't throw them off. Neither does having one or two core families on vacation.

Laurie Graham 4:04
In a small church, you know how it goes. One week could require a fully staffed nursery, and an extra volunteer in Sunday school because a new family walked in. But another week, you might find yourself fully staffed, but no kids show up because maybe two of your families got hit with the flu. So it seems impossible to predict who you'll need and when. It's difficult to recruit a staff when the needs vary not only by the season, but by the week with little consistency.

Today, I'm going to share a few unexpected quick wins to add a few more volunteers to your roster. I'm also going to talk about some longer-term strategies that work toward building a committed team in your future. We're also going to talk about why taking better care of your current volunteers needs to move up on your priority list even if you are the only volunteer. We're also going to talk about how your current recruiting methods might actually be turning people away instead of drawing them in.

Here we go. I'm guessing you're going to want the quick wins first because we all need more volunteers. I don't mind starting with the quick wins, if you promise to hang with me till the end, because here's the thing, the quick wins usually aren't the things that sustain long-term changes, at least not on their own. If you want lasting change, you'll be better off embracing the longer-term strategies we're going to talk about. The longer-term strategies are just that they're long-term. It's the slower route to foundational changes, but these foundational changes will totally change your ministry. Foundational changes don't happen so quickly, but they last. I do know you need volunteers now, and you don't just need a plan for a few years down the road.

Let's get to some solutions for today, I want to give you both the short term, the quick wins, and also the longer term. As you practice the long term strategies, you're going to change the trajectory of your church ministry to children, you don't need to struggle with finding volunteers forever. In fact, team building gets a lot more fun when you have a long term plan and tools that work. Throw in some consistency and following the plan and you're totally on your way to a really different future.

Laurie Graham 6:16
If you haven't heard my philosophy on small churches and volunteers, we're going to start with that. This belief is absolutely why I can confidently share with you what I'm about to share. I believe you already have all the volunteers you need in your church, to do exactly what God has in mind for you to do. We don't need more to do what God wants us to do. We also don't need to do more than God wants us to do, but we don't need to do less either. So Philippians 4:19 says “God will meet all my needs in Christ Jesus.” 2 Corinthians 9:8 says, “And God is able to bless you abundantly so that in all things at all times, having all that you need, you will abound in every good work.”

I am totally not a name it and claim it person. I am not saying that we're going to have all our needs met because we declare it. I'm saying we have it because God set up the body of Christ that way. In 1 Corinthians when Paul illustrates the body of Christ as a physical body, you know, there was a foot and a hand and all these things are working together. It says God put the body together. The church is not like an old Mr. Potatohead toy that's missing an eye or a foot. No, God made us to be the church, and He made the church to be the light of the world. He didn't create us to represent a body that has missing body parts. I believe the church is supposed to function as a representative of Christ to the world, which means that God has given us what we need to do that well.

In addition, the Bible says they'll know we are Christians by— by what? By our programs, by events? No. By our love, by our fruits. We also need to quit measuring our success by programs and by attendance. If we're limping along with missing pieces and parts, nobody's going to be drawn to Christ. Also, if we're serving, bitter, broken, or burnt out, nobody's going to be drawn to Christ.

Laurie Graham 8:26
If we're doing what God has provided, and equipped us to do, no more, no less. I think that is living in His kingdom. That is what's going to draw people to Christ. We can serve well out of the abundance that God has poured into us. I'm not talking about material abundance, that's just fluff. I'm talking about our hearts, our cups overflowing are reflecting His image in the fruits of the Spirit, which is only possible when we're abiding in Him taking care of ourselves and of each other, when we're serving out of joy, out of abundance of love and being filled up.

For the sake of this podcast, can you agree with me that God's already provided what you need for your church to do exactly what He has in mind? Even if it doesn't feel like that? What if it's true? What if you already have all the volunteers you need to do exactly what God has in mind? Let's start there. How do we go about uncovering these gifts? Raising people up, developing servants and adding to our children's ministry volunteers?

We're starting with the quick wins. I've got three of them for you. The first one is this: make the jobs smaller and more fun, and look for specialists. Here's the thing about children's ministry. If you're new to children's ministry, it's crazy intimidating. I know it might not seem like it to you, because you're doing it, but it is to most people. There is a lot of responsibility in children's ministry, you're caring for somebody's baby, whether they're two or twelve, or twenty. There's a lot of personality and a lot of varying opinions in this area. The commitment is big.

Unfortunately, it's kind of our fault that many people run for the hills when you ask for teachers or VBS volunteers, because people have had a lot of negative experience in children's ministry, either as a volunteer themselves, or even when they were a kid in church. They remember how mean kids were to their teachers, or they remember when they volunteered, thought they were volunteering for an hour, and got stuck for a year. I know it's happened to a lot of us. The average Sunday school teacher, think about it, has as many jobs as a parent, and they're supposed to be good at them all.

Laurie Graham 10:49
Here's a few jobs that I can name off the top of my head. A Sunday School teacher serves as number one, a behavior specialist. Number two, a child development expert. Number three, an educator. How about a comforter, a nurse, a psychologist, a Bible scholar, a Sunday school teacher also has to be a facilities manager and artist, a janitor and activities director, a game leader, a liaison to parents, a motivational speaker, a host a welcomer and a registrar. Right?
There's more, I just mentioned, I think 15 or 16. I promise you, there's more.

Nowhere else in the church do we expect one volunteer to be an expert at so many things. Can you imagine? The guitar player? If you have a contemporary band. Well, what do they need to do? They just need to play the guitar. A small group leader? How about helping at a women's ministry event? Do they have to be experts at 15 things? How about somebody who brings the snacks or volunteers on the prayer team, or a part of the outreach committee, I am telling you, there are no other jobs in a church that has so many responsibilities.

Here's the quick win: invite volunteers to do less, break the jobs down, make it easier, make it smaller, pair them up, serve in teams. Instead of asking for another teacher to do it all. To be a master of all these things. Try finding a greeter, a craft leader, a Bible story reader, an empathetic listener to do the prayer time. Believe me, I would have loved somebody helping me with that, because I can totally lead the games but my patients cracks a little bit when I'm listening to the littles for extended times. It's all about finding specialists.

The other great thing about finding specialists is not only are they good at that thing, but because they're good at it, they enjoy it, they have fun. They feel successful, they're happier to show up. It's much harder to show up when you're stressed, or you feel like you're failing or you can't do a good job. So make it easier for people to succeed, make the jobs smaller. When you make them smaller, they're more fun.

Laurie Graham 13:02
I know this sounds like more people and not less, but you will find more people who are willing to do less and to do their smaller jobs very well. If you're tempted to say this is not going to work, and that you will not find more people to do less things. I would just ask that you try it first. Before you even try it, pray about it. Meditate on some of the scriptures I mentioned. Pray about what God really has for your church. If everyone happens to say no, it is possible that you're trying to do more than God wants you to do at your small church in this moment in time.

Keep Mr. Potatohead in mind, your church is not missing any parts. Sometimes small churches are trying to do different things than God has called us to do. Remember, the goal isn't to mimic the big church culture. It's to mimic Jesus. There are beautiful things that only small churches have to offer. Small church ministry is not less, please hear me it's not less, but it is different. If you want even more help with volunteers, go back and listen to the podcast episodes 10 through 15. It's a five-part series just on volunteers in any ministry area, so check them out if you haven't yet.

What do you think so far? Have you tried this? Have you tried breaking jobs into smaller pieces? If not, that's my first best tip for a quick win, but here's another: My second best tip. Make serving as partners or in pairs, the norm. Always have a team. This is a quick win. change up your structure to always serve with a partner. Your volunteer can even pick their partner. If your children's ministry positions are always partner positions, it's a lot easier on people. They share the load, they encourage each other, they feel more supported.

Laurie Graham 15:01
The reality is in most small churches, there's not always a children's pastor, paid or unpaid. There's not always a Christian ed director. There's not always a Sunday school supervisor. In fact, you listening right now might be the sole teacher or the only kids leader in your church right now. Who is supposed to support you? So many volunteers feel like they're on their own. If you change the culture starting with you, and volunteers always serve in teams or pairs, and you set them up to feel like that's normal, this is the way we do things, you'll be keeping your volunteers happier, and also developing new volunteers by default. This is a team position, who might serve with you?

One quick safety aside on picking partners, one of the safety concerns in children's ministry, in addition to having background checks, is not having only family members serving in a closed room. The reason for this is protection of the volunteers and the children. In the case of abuse, if there's an abuser in the family, many times family members enable the abuser or look the other way. If you've ever wondered why many safety standards say no husband and wife, team, or no daddy daughter team, that's why. It doesn't count as your two adults in a room. It's valid so please don't ignore or dismiss safety standards, they exist for a reason.

If two family members are on your team, there should always be a third unrelated adult in the room. I know that safety standards sometimes feel limiting or restrictive, but if we can understand and communicate the “why” we can totally turn standards into celebrations. It actually can feel really freeing, knowing that we will do whatever we need to do to make this the safest place on earth. Wouldn’t that be amazing? If our churches were the safest place for people, emotionally, physically, psychologically, spiritually, so beautiful.

Laurie Graham 17:05
All right, third quick win: shorten the time commitments. Number one was making jobs smaller. Number two was starting to institute partner ministry or teams. Number three is shorten the time commitment. When we talk about shortening the time commitment, I'm not talking about shortening Sunday morning, or shortening your nursery time, but I'm talking about the start and end dates of a term of commitment. Like I'll teach Sunday school from September to May. If you're thinking right now, “we don't even have that, like there's no start and end date, please don't make my heart stop.”

Anytime you ask a volunteer to do something, there should be a super clear start date and end date. If it's an ongoing position, and you hope they stay forever, that end date is the time when you get to renew and stay longer if it's a good fit. It's also permission to be done or to take a break. This is another reason why lots of churches can't get children's ministry helpers. Historically, it's often an eternal commitment, like it's the never ending labor of love. That's not right, it's not healthy, and it's not smart. If you're doing better than most churches, maybe you have people sign up for a year commitment, which is totally great.

If you've got a healthy volunteer culture with a track record of supporting your very happy team. If not, though, shorten the time commitment to one month on or one month off or serving for a season. This often works better for families or people who travel. Like when my girls played soccer, there was no way I could serve in the fall, but spring? I could do that. If it was only a full year position, you just lost me as a volunteer, and I'm a great volunteer. You have those people in your church. All right. So those were your few quick wins for faster results when you want to get some new volunteers now and not just later, make the job smaller, have people serve in teams as a norm, and shorten the time commitment and or.

Laurie Graham19:11
On to long term strategies. If you stick to the long term strategies I'm about to talk about and stay consistent. They're going to change everything. This is where we're gonna get into taking better care of your current volunteers. This needs to move up in your priority list, even if it's just you. The other thing we're going to talk about is a common but often overlooked reason why your recruiting methods might not be working.

Let's start with taking better care of your volunteers first. If you aren't taking care of your current volunteers, and this means you too. You're not going to build the team you want. You aren't going to find the volunteers you need and you're not going to grow the kids ministry that you dream of. Hands down, it's a loss. You need to take care of your current volunteers, even if it's just one, or if it's just you. This is why: Your current volunteers are the most accurate representatives of your ministry. If they are burnout, crabby, overstretched or bitter, who wants that?

When's the last time you looked for a job like actually hunted for a day job, I'm going to tell you in my town, there's a big box retail store pretty close to where I am. The employees look like they hate coming to work. They are crabby with customers and even with each other, they hardly ever smile, they walk very slowly with their heads hanging down. They don't even look like they're friends with the people they work with. No happy conversations going on there. Then, if I drive a few miles away, and go to Costco, everything's different.

At Costco, at least the one in my town, every employee always looks happy. I literally have never seen a grumpy employee at Costco, even in the middle of the pandemic. How do they do this? Is the Costco the same by you? Every employee looks excited to be at work. They're chatting, they're smiling. If you compare this Costco with the big box retail store I described and you were looking for a job, where would you want to work? I'd rather work at Costco. That other place must be a miserable place to work.

Laurie Graham 21:33
Here's the question for you. What do the volunteers in your kid's ministry look like? What about you if you're the only one serving? I am not saying to fake it. I'm not saying to look like you're happy to get more volunteers. I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying treat them well and take care of them so that they actually are happy to serve, take care of you. You should not serve when you're sick. You should take time off to go to adult worship when you need to. You should be growing as a disciple growing in skill, building friendships. This is healthy ministry.

For possible future volunteers, what they see of your ministry is so much more impactful than what you say about your ministry. If you're saying that working with kids is a gift from God, and that they'll have support and find joy, and they see ragged, bitter volunteers. Do you think that'll have an impact on those possible new volunteers? You bet it will. They're going to stay clear, because it looks like a miserable place to work. The state of your current volunteers has a direct correlation with your recruiting new volunteers. If you're thinking that people should just serve miserable, because it's a job that needs to be done, I totally disagree. I do not think that's very Jesus like, and I don't think that's what He wants for you either.

If you can't maintain the ministry you're doing with happy volunteers, something is off. Either you're doing too much or maybe you're not doing it in a way that's customized to the people that God brought to your church who God provided. There are so many creative ways of staffing and of setting up Sunday school and nursery and kids ministry, even if you're short staffed. Creative ways will meet the needs you have. Please hear that, it will meet the needs you have. Not necessarily all the wants, but the needs? Yes, because God says that. The need to do exactly what God has for you to do. Again, you don't need to do more and you also don't need to do less. That's your first long term strategy that will change everything in children's ministry, and honestly, every other ministry in your church too. Take care of your volunteers, even if it's you, make them or you, and you, a priority.

Laurie Graham 24:09
Here's my second long term strategy I'm going to leave you with. Just be about building better relationships in your church, love people, and not for the purpose of getting them to serve or join your team, that actually would fall under the nasty word of manipulation. I've learned more about the word manipulation in the past year. I always thought it was kind of an extreme word, like just nasty people manipulate people. It turns out that we do that a lot on a normal basis. Many of us, all of us.

You see, if you're doing something with the goal of getting someone else to do something, that's manipulation. We all have free choice. We choose our own actions and behaviors. If your goal is to get someone to choose differently, it's manipulation. Unfortunately, it's also really common in the church. We need a volunteer so we set out to find one. The opposite of manipulation is just loving people with no agenda. That is pretty awesome. That's God's church. What if our goal in loving people was simply to get to know the image of God in them, to hear their dreams, to help them find their joy and freedom and encourage them to follow God's plan for them. To help them realize their awesomeness, the beauty God's put in them, the gifts, the skills, the talents, the desires? Wouldn't that be amazing? To just get to know people and love them with no agenda?

If you believe that God puts the body together, and he has these eyes, and these feet and these legs, and these arms and these kidneys all together for a purpose, then God's gonna bring it about. As we all grow, and start to fit together as the Body of Christ, we'll find our places in ministry as God designed it. You see, we'll see opportunities for invitation, but we'll also honor people's decisions. To do this all well, it's basically the craziest trust walk you've ever taken because we have to trust that God's got it. We have to trust in His plan, more than our plan, we have to trust that His design for our churches is about Him and not us. Also not about what we see other churches doing.

Laurie Graham 26:31
Then if we're trusting him like that, we release our desperation for volunteers, because God's the head of the church, not us. We release our need to be needed, even ourselves. We release our need to control the outcome, we release our workaholism. Is there such a thing as ministry or holism? Wonder what that would be, if that's not a word, it should be. You see, God did not call us to be martyrs in the church, martyrs in ministry? No. He did not call us to carry this heavy load and burn ourselves out and feel like without us, no ministry would happen. It's not true. If you serve because no one else will, I hear that a lot. “Well, I'm doing it all, because no one else will.” That is not God's truth.

If He's really the head of the church, we've got to trust Him to be the head of the church. Because when one person is doing it all, or almost it all, it leads to all sorts of trouble, including too much dependence on one person, unhealthy relationships, pride, imbalance in the church body, other people not realizing their gifts, or their need to be part of the body, burnout, just all sorts of unhealthy. You, my friend, are responsible for your heart and your health. No one else is. That responsibility to guard your heart is a big one, and it's from God.

If you haven't read my illustration on The Runner and the Sailor, please check it out. The link is in the show notes. It's one of the first posts I wrote for The Creative Little Church website on no more burnout. I truly believe it's foundational in understanding God's call on our lives. Volunteers burning out and serving in unhealth is not a sign of their commitment. It is not a badge of honor. It is not an accurate representation of the Body of Christ, or how God set us up to be the church.

I kind of looped back here to the first long term strategy that was taking care of your volunteers. The second was building better relationships with no strings attached, but they are very related. Once we're taking care of ourselves, and we are trusting God with His purpose for our church, we are freed up to build better relationships with no strings attached. Both of these long term strategies are going to serve you well. They are a little bit counterculture in our modern small church mentality but I believe that they are very aligned to Scripture, and to the example of Jesus Christ Himself.

Laurie Graham 29:19
Of course, there are lots of other long term strategies we could chat about, but you are probably almost done with your walk, your drive to church or wherever you're listening from. I just want to remind you don't forget about episodes 10 through 15. They have lots more on volunteers if you're looking for that. We've also got an entire website of resources just for small churches, and a comprehensive small church ministry training at The Small Church Academy. The Small Church Academy— there is nothing like it on the planet. This is where we take all these concepts and we don't just talk about them, but we break them into bite sized actionable pieces and myths. except with it individual support and feedback, so that you can make an impact in your church and community like nothing else you've ever imagined, right where God has you.

The Small Church Academy opens its doors to new members with each conference, which are quarterly. It's only open for about a week to join so get your name on the list or jump in for a free 30 day trial. The free 30 day trial also includes a one on one strategy call with me. We're actually talking about the program and see if it's even a fit for you. It's a great place to ask your questions and learn more. Plus, we get to meet together on Zoom, and I personally would love to meet you. So check out The Small Church Academy and also our upcoming conference in the links in the show notes.

I cannot wait to talk to you next week. Before I go, though, who do you know who needs to hear this episode on getting more volunteers or just on being healthy themselves? Would you do me a favor, and them a favor too, and send them a link to this podcast? It's a great way to keep the conversation going and encourage more people in small churches everywhere. So until next week, be a light.




Keep going

Join 38,000+ people in small churches growing together, one email at a time.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.