Sign in
← All episodes

Podcast · Leadership & Pastors · November 25, 2025

204: Models That Work: Paid Pastors, Bi-Vocational Leaders, and Fully Volunteer Churches | Church Finance Series (Part 2)

Churches think there’s only one real model of leadership. Churches exist in every structure: fully paid, bi-vocational, and completely volunteer-led.

A large part of a small church budget often goes to paying the pastor. Most small churches assume there’s only one “real” model of leadership - usually the one we’ve always known - and anything different feels like failure, pride, or danger.

But there’s no single “biblical” or “more noble” model here. Healthy, vibrant churches exist in every structure: fully paid, bi-vocational, and completely volunteer-led.

This episode lifts the shame, clears out the judgment, and helps churches learn:

  1. Why there isn’t one “right” model (and why that’s such good news)
  2. How assumptions, pride, and tradition shape our views without us noticing
  3. The strengths + limits of paid, bi-vocational, and volunteer pastor models
  4. Why most tension around leadership positions come from unspoken expectations
  5. How to discern whether it’s time to rethink your model when things feel stretched or scary

We turned this episode into a full blog series that explores:

All of these insights lead to our pillar post: 3 Small Church Leadership Models That Works.

Links Mentioned:

Join our free Facebook Community: www.facebook.com/groups/smallchurchministry

Rate, Review, & Follow on Apple Podcasts

If you love The Small Church Ministry Podcast, please consider rating and reviewing the show! This helps us support more people -- just like you -- in small churches! Click here, scroll to the bottom of the page, tap to rate with five stars, and select “Write a Review.” Then let us know what you loved most about this show!

Also, follow The Small Church Ministry podcast! This is the best way to stay up to date on the new episodes that are released every week. Be sure to follow now so you don't miss out!

Listen On:

TranscriptLaurie Graham 0:01
Hey, welcome to the Small Church Ministry Podcast, where we help volunteers and ministry leaders experience less stress, more joy, and greater impact as we share strategies that actually do work in smaller churches. I'm your host, Laurie Graham. Let's dive in.

Laurie Graham 0:23
Hey, friend, welcome back to the Small Church Ministry Podcast. We are in Part Two of a church finance series today. We're stepping into a topic that can get a little emotional, a little difficult at times. We're going to be talking about pastoral salary and leadership models.

Laurie Graham 0:39
Now, if you are popping into the small church ministry podcast for the first time. We don't usually talk church finances. We have tons of episodes on finding and developing volunteers, staffing well when you feel like you're understaffed, women's ministry, children's ministry, worship and tons more. So feel free to have some fun kind of flitting through all of our episodes. If this one isn't going to float your boat because the church finance series, well, we're going there.

Laurie Graham 0:57
So again, as I mentioned, pastoral salary and leadership models is what we're popping into today. Last week, we talked about a few things that had a lot to do with reframing the way we look at things, the way we feel about things. There's the Church, and then there's the 501(c)(3) or the nonprofit or the institution. So we separated the church out of that. If you did not catch that episode, really want you to go back and listen to Episode 203. It kind of sets the foundation of where I'm coming from.

Laurie Graham 1:43
The context for these next several episodes, when we look honestly at small church budgets, which is why we're talking about this today. Often a large percentage of the budget is for the pastor's salary. When money gets tight, sometimes that's the first fear that we have: that we can't afford a pastor, or that we're going to cut that salary. The fear is real. We are not going to be able to talk about every aspect of this, but we are going to talk about the ways that thinking of the leadership model really touches all parts of our identity, especially when we're fearful that we have to make some changes. It touches us, spiritually, emotionally, relationally, and before we dive deeper in, I just want to say something that matters a lot, and there is nothing wrong with a pastor who needs a full-time salary. That's not selfish, it's not unspiritual, it's not a lack of faith. It's completely valid for a pastor to desire stable income, benefits, rest, margin, to care well, not only for their family and people in their personal lives, but also for the people of the church. Wanting full-time ministry to be financially sustainable isn't the problem. The problem is when a church's reality can't meet that need, and we don't deal with that very well.

Laurie Graham 3:08
There's also nothing wrong with being a bi-vocational pastor or a volunteer pastor. Every model can be super healthy, and we're going to walk through all of them, because we've seen it over and over again. As I've been relating to small churches, thousands of them, hearing stories, having conversations, running online conferences, running online communities, being part of the network, we have seen models where full-time pastors in small churches are super healthy. We've seen models in small churches where a bi-vocational pastor working two different jobs is really healthy. We've also seen many small churches running on a completely volunteer model are also super healthy.

Laurie Graham 4:00
So any model can work. I'm not here endorsing one model over the other. It's not the model that creates the success or the pressure, but not understanding, not sharing expectations, not setting up these models well, can cause a lot of issues.

Laurie Graham 4:21
As we're in the finance series this time, by the end of the episode, we're going to take the pressure all the way down so that you can walk away with a way to evaluate leadership models without any shame on either direction, maybe a little more language that takes the guilt out of shifting from one model to another, some clarity on what's sustainable today with the church body that you have now, not five years ago, and also you'll walk away with a reminder that change in a model, one way or the other, is not a spiritual downgrade at all, it's wisdom.

Laurie Graham 5:07
So everybody together. Let's take a big, deep, collective breath. Nobody's behind, nobody's failing. We are going to get honest, and that's how real healthy churches begin and grow.

Laurie Graham 5:22
So let's get into it. We're going to start by naming something around this topic that hopefully will remove a lot of weight off of the whole concept of if your pastors are paid or not, or how much. And that's where I want to say there is not a single biblical or correct or more spiritual leadership model for any church.

Laurie Graham 5:50
Some of us grew up believing that a real church has a full-time pastor paid. Some of us grew up believing that a bi-vocational pastor is more humble and more relatable or more noble, because it's the tentmaker thing, right? Like Paul. Some of us grew up believing that if a pastor isn't paid, that the church must be struggling. Or on the flip side, if a pastor isn't paid, that pastor has a calling because they don't need to be paid.

Laurie Graham 6:21
Now I want to say none of that is scripture. This is culture, this is tradition. This is maybe what we've always known or something that we have been taught. But churches across history, all around the world, have thrived under every different model.

Laurie Graham 6:42
And here's one of the harder parts: is when we inherit a model, we usually inherit the assumptions that are attached to it. Let me say that again. When we inherit a model, the church you're in, for instance, we usually inherit the assumptions that were attached to that model. These assumptions might sound like this:

Laurie Graham 7:05
"If we change the model, are we failing?"

Laurie Graham 7:09
"What would happen if we change the model? We might be sending the wrong message. People might think we're dying."

Laurie Graham 7:19
"What will the pastor think? Will they think they're not valued or they're valued more, or they're valued less?"

Laurie Graham 7:31
"Will this disrupt the congregation if we change the leadership model?"

Laurie Graham 7:38
Now, this is where pride and fear and comparison can really sneak in, sometimes quietly, sometimes it's not that quiet, because a church that's always had a full-time pastor can suddenly feel very wrong or even ashamed if they shift to having a bi-vocational pastor. Or a church that maybe has seen themselves as super missional because they've never paid a pastor, they've always had a volunteer staff. "Are we selling out? Are we giving up on the model that involves everyone working together, if we hire a pastor?" So this really can go both ways. Sometimes a church with a volunteer pastor maybe feels defensive, like they have to prove that they're legitimate, even though they don't pay their pastor, but Scripture really has shown multiple expressions of leadership. And healthy churches today who deeply love Jesus and are serving faithfully show every expression of these different models.

Laurie Graham 8:48
But just looking at Scripture, we know that Paul worked and preached, right? Bi-vocational. We know that some leaders were financially supported, but others were not. We see examples of this, Old Testament, New Testament. We see ministry teams. Maybe they weren't called ministry teams, but groups of people shared responsibility: elders, teachers, prophets—that was plural, not singular.

Laurie Graham 9:18
There wasn't one perfect model that was exemplified in Scripture, like, "This is the way it should always be done," and there isn't one perfect model today.

Laurie Graham 9:28
Now, if you're listening in and you're like, "You've never seen these other models," that's okay. That's pretty normal. Many people who grew up in a church that has a paid pastor, even if we've changed churches multiple times, we look for churches with paid pastors because it's what we've known. But just so you know, there are models of this all over the place.

Laurie Graham 9:50
I know over the past year, just in our community, in our Facebook community, our Creative Solutions for Small Churches, I've had several conversations and calls with many people in there who are in fully volunteer churches. And they they're not all tiny. Like, sometimes, when we think a church that has volunteer pastors, we think of home churches or micro churches, or churches that have 30. I know fully volunteer churches who don't pay staff at all, who are upwards of 100, 200, and even higher than that, worshiping on a Sunday. So please don't equate these models with size either, because I also know churches of under 50 who pay a full-time pastor.

Laurie Graham 10:36
So these different models of leadership, whether you have paid pastors, bi-vocational pastors, or fully volunteer pastors, or whatever you call your leadership, it's not a signal or a sign of success, financial success, numerical success, spiritual success. It's just a different way of doing things.

Laurie Graham 11:01
But one great question to ask is, "What is honest and what's sustainable for our people?"—for the people who worship here, for our congregation, not what's sustainable for the people we wish we had, or the imaginary version of our church from 1997 or from 1950, because your church, the church that's there now, the people, it's right now, it's today.

Laurie Graham 11:33
I had to laugh. I've had this conversation with my friend Becky, and also on our other podcast that talks about building businesses as Christian women. So this conversation has come up in several different places. But my friend Becky and I were talking a couple of weeks ago, and she has struggled with insomnia and just some different physical issues over the past couple of years. And she said, "Yeah, I think I'm coming to the point where I need to realistically make decisions based on the body I have, not on the body that I wish I had or I used to have." And man, doesn't that have implications for us even today? Like, can we look at and evaluate and be realistic and honest, as well as hopeful, but really considering the body, the church body that we have, not the one that we wish we had, or the one that we used to have, but who we actually have. Because when we start there, things can get a lot calmer, especially when we go back to last episode, when I talked about we're not talking about sustaining the Church. Jesus sustains the Church. We're talking about building or sustaining or growing—not growing in number, but like growing in health—the nonprofit, the institution that exists to support the Church.

Laurie Graham 12:54
So picture your church with me, the real one, not the idealized one, the faces, the stories, the seasons that our people are in. So this is who the model needs to serve when we think about the institution, the nonprofit, the people who are in our church, and also the people who are outside our walls.

Laurie Graham 13:21
So as I mentioned, the different models of leadership—paying, not paying, bi-vocational pastors, etc.—these are just tools. This isn't a rank, this isn't an award, this isn't a measure of faithfulness or success. It's just a different way of doing things. So I just want to walk through the different models of pastors.

Laurie Graham 13:42
Now, again, we're in a finance series, because paying pastors is a lot of our finances. Now this doesn't mean that your financial state is the only reason you make a decision on which model. That's why I'm going to walk through the strengths and some of the limitations of each model. One is not like strikingly better than the other. They all have some pros and cons. Finances are not the only reason that plays in, but it typically is a big part of a small church budget.

Laurie Graham 14:10
So okay, paying your pastor. Now, whether you have a single pastor or a multiple pastoral staff, we know we have many churches who listen in with less than 50 people, 100 people on a Sunday, 300 people on the Sunday, larger, smaller, and in between. So we're just talking about paid pastors.

Laurie Graham 14:29
There's a lot of strengths for paying your pastors.

Laurie Graham 14:32
One of the biggest strengths is more hours dedicated to ministry and visibility in your community.

Laurie Graham 14:37
There may be more stability for planning and programs because of the amount of hours, because of that paid pastor model.

Laurie Graham 14:51
And oftentimes there's more emotional bandwidth—depending on the personality of your pastor, of course—but emotional bandwidth for pastoral care.

Laurie Graham 15:00
Because many pastors are doing a lot of the leadership edge of running the institution, the church building, the nonprofit side of things, right? The leadership that if all those hours are fitting into a bi-vocational setting, they don't always have as much hours for pastoral care. So the paid pastor model: those are some of the strengths.

Laurie Graham 15:21
Now here's some of the limits or pressures or things that can be a little bit negative. Paid pastors often feel a pressure to earn their salary. When we're getting paid to do something, sometimes there's a pressure from the pastors themselves, as well as a pressure from congregants.

Laurie Graham 15:43
Congregants sometimes measure the faithfulness of that pastor by not only the hours they worked, but what they did in those hours.

Laurie Graham 15:51
There's a little more control.

Laurie Graham 15:53
Sometimes, when we have paid pastors, there's an expectation to do everything.

Laurie Graham 15:59
Sometimes there's a little bit of pressure to do more because they're paid, where they don't want to put as much on a volunteer, and sometimes we lose that priesthood of all believers, or more of the volunteer expectation.

Laurie Graham 16:15
Sometimes there's a demand for productivity that feels rather business-like, because there is money exchanged.

Laurie Graham 16:21
Paid pastors sometimes say something like this: "I feel like, if I'm not doing everything, I'm failing the church," or "I feel like, because I'm paid, I shouldn't ask someone else to do this." In all those things, I will say, "No, no, those aren't true. We're all human. We all need each other. We were called to community. In addition to that, even if you're paid, you're human, you're not a ministry robot."

Laurie Graham 16:49
So that's a little bit about paying your pastors full-time. Now, let's talk about some of the strengths of a bi-vocational model. Love my friend Tony Bryce in the UK. He's been on several podcasts. He's spoken at several of our conferences. He actually was one of the first people I knew who said he loved being bi-vocational. He loved being bi-vocational. He shared that it gave him a really different perspective in ministry. He loves his job that he works, and he loves being able to do both. So bi-vocational doesn't mean that that means you can't afford it, or that that person isn't as committed, or anything like that. Bi-vocational is a choice. It's an option. For many people, it's a strength.

Laurie Graham 17:36
So here's some great things about the bi-vocational pastoral model: deeply connected to real life and real people, because they are. They're not in the church bubble. They're outside the church bubble for a lot of their time.

Laurie Graham 17:52
Sometimes there's a different type of humility that comes and relatability, because they are in the world working all the time, a regular human job.

Laurie Graham 18:04
Sometimes the bi-vocational model, another strength, can be sometimes healthier boundaries, because they have some automatic boundaries. Now I'm not saying all bi-vocational pastors have great boundaries. I would say in all of these models, you can have pastors who are healthy and pastors who are less healthy, but there's some forced boundaries if you're in a bi-vocational model.

Laurie Graham 18:27
And also finances. There is a strength, because finances aren't always such a big determining factor.

Laurie Graham 18:35
Sometimes the bi-vocational pastors don't need as much income. It's just not as much pressure, because maybe their benefits come from somewhere else. Now, sometimes they're also super strapped, which gets into Church Health. It is not what we're talking about today.

Laurie Graham 18:50
Limitations: So let's just take the bi-vocational model as it is, some predictable limits, or sometimes some downsides. Is there is limited bandwidth? There's less availability, because they're working another job. Sometimes people in the congregation misinterpret capacity as a lack of care, like, "Why aren't they showing up? Don't they care?" Well, no, they have another job. And for some bi-vocational pastors, they may feel like pulled between two callings or two jobs. Bi-vocational pastors sometimes feel judged like they're less committed, which is absolutely not true. Sometimes bi-vocational pastors may feel judged as they're less effective because they don't have as many hours. And I have to be honest, I've seen really, really amazing, super effective bi-vocational pastoral models in smaller churches, because there's a different edge of focus. Limited time means we're a little more focused. Or can mean that. Okay?

Laurie Graham 19:51
The third model is just a completely volunteer pastoral model. This is when your pastor, or multiple pastors, don't get paid at all. They work other jobs, have other commitments, and they volunteer as pastors.

Laurie Graham 20:05
Some great strengths to this is it's really relational.

Laurie Graham 20:09
It's very sustainable for even the tiniest churches.

Laurie Graham 20:13
It's often deeply communal, like we're all connected, we're all the same.

Laurie Graham 20:18
There's zero financial pressure on the church.

Laurie Graham 20:21
Now, some of the limitations is this requires extremely clear boundaries. All three models, in my mind, to be healthy, require shared expectations all over the place. But in this edge, we really need extremely clear boundaries if the pastoral staff is all volunteer.

Laurie Graham 20:42
It can slip into this mode of, "I always feel like I'm on," which is like that when we just feel always activated and always needed.

Laurie Graham 20:52
Sometimes, when we're volunteers, congregations sometimes can devalue the role because we're not paying them, they're just a volunteer. So again, it's a possible limitation, a possible downside, not always, and honestly, the churches that I know of where pastors are volunteers, that's not an issue. They're pretty highly valued.

Laurie Graham 21:16
And just another, you know, downside can be that there's a big emotional load with no paycheck as a buffer, right? So volunteer pastors carry so much calling, often with the least cultural validation, at least from other churches who see this model.

Laurie Graham 21:38
None of these models—paid, bi-vocational, or volunteer—is more noble than the others. They're just different ways of stewarding what's real. So please think about that word stewardship again. We're in a series on finances. There are options on church leadership. These are all valid options.

Laurie Graham 22:04
So let's pause just for a minute. I want you to think about your model. Think about the model of your church. Do you pay your pastors or pastor? Is it a bi-vocational model? Are they volunteer? Think about the gifts that this model brings to your church. We just named a bunch. And also think about the challenges that come with it. Each model carries its own challenges, probably tons of gifts and challenges that I didn't even name, but not from judgment, but just from honesty. Just think about it, and consider that there's other ways.

Laurie Graham 22:44
I do want to, before we close up this episode, I really want to talk about judgment and expectations and tension, and honestly, I'll even say abuses, because when we have someone on staff, whether it's volunteer or not, there is a part where things get really personal, that can get really hard, but also can be really freeing.

Laurie Graham 23:14
If you are hiring a full-time pastor, a bi-vocational pastor, or a volunteer pastor, can we be real about job descriptions, about expectations? Can we also be real about ourselves if we're the ones getting hired or promoted here? Because if you are the pastor, you are responsible first to yourself, to your own health, your own relationships, and we've got to be realistic about what we can carry and what we can't. Because we're not robots. We're not called to sacrifice our lives and our health for the church institution. We're really not, because that does nobody any good.

Laurie Graham 24:01
At every single online conference we do, anytime I speak, almost, I will always have an edge to me that says, "Be healthy." It's not their job to keep you healthy. It's not your spouse's job to keep you healthy. It's not the congregation's job to keep you healthy. We are responsible for ourselves, whether we're volunteered or paid. And so, as I said way up at the beginning of this episode, there's nothing wrong with a vocational pastor, needing, wanting, desiring, choosing to be paid full-time, but let's be real about our needs, about our expectations. Let's get on the same page. A bi-vocational pastor who's juggling maybe three worlds, we need to be real about what we need, about what we can handle, about what the congregation is asking from us, and can we make these asks instead of demands?

Laurie Graham 25:04
Sometimes we think what they demand from us or what we are demanding from our pastor. Please make sure these are agreed upon. A lot of times the expectations from our congregation, they're not written, they're not shared. The expectations as a pastor we may have may not be shared. Open communication, talking about these things, sharing the load, making sure that there isn't resentment, or we're not creating models of burnout or bitterness. We need to get rid of the silence around what's expected or when we feel like things are failing around us. Let's be a community that shares and talks and over-communicates.

Laurie Graham 25:57
I am a big fan of clear, written job descriptions, even and especially for volunteers, even if the role, not kidding, is bringing cookies to a lock-in. I really support a written job description, even if it's a one-sentence, casual, and fun: "This is how we'll know we're doing a good job."

Laurie Graham 26:24
Paid pastors often feel guilty because they're not doing enough, not meeting expectations, even though they're doing three people's jobs. Bi-vocational pastors often feel looked down on or a lot of pressure, maybe as if a second job makes them less dedicated, when capacity is not about care. Volunteer pastors sometimes feel a little invisible or maybe unvalued, caring real calling and real responsibility and real pressure, but sometimes, in some circumstances, hearing, well, "One day when we can hire a real pastor," right?

Laurie Graham 27:14
All three of these models are valid. They can be super healthy, but only when expectations are clear, when we're sharing mission and vision, when we're looking at who's carrying what part of what loads, because the model is never the problem. Sometimes we attach a hierarchy to a model, that can be a problem when we think one model is better than the other, or we're doing that little stair-stepping to get to a new model. I'd like to just throw that thought out, just completely out of the room, that all of these models can be beautiful and healthy and effective and highly impacting, but the shame or the pride or the comparison, those kind of things get in the way, or that thought I mentioned earlier, where what we're used to feels like what's right and we don't want to make a change.

Laurie Graham 28:24
So if you are leading, if you're the one leading in any capacity, paid or unpaid, let's just clearly say no one's calling is validated by a paycheck. None of us. Nobody's faithfulness is measured in hours. That includes you volunteer who's listening. Nobody's worth is tied to any kind of budget line, none of us.

Laurie Graham 28:48
So let's let it sink in. Now, because we're in a finance series, I just want to get into this just a little bit, because many people may be listening to this series because their church is facing some tough times. Maybe it feels bleak, maybe you feel a little stretched, and truly this can be time to rethink the model. Now this isn't just like sad. This is also where hope begins.

Laurie Graham 29:20
Instead of seeing changing the model as something bad or bleak, let's look at it as, "Hey. Let's move into a different place." If your budget numbers are shrinking, instead of seeing that as failure, let's just look at that as data. Let's take the emotion out of the numbers. It's just data. Instead of interpreting it as failure or a lack of faithfulness or sin or a lack of commitment or "something's wrong with the pastor or the people or the church," can we just take the emotion out of it and say, "Hey, what if this was just information and not failure? What if this is information as to who we are today, where we're at?" Because when we can look at it as information, not failure, a leadership model is just something to match with reality, right?

Laurie Graham 30:24
Sometimes the model we're hanging on to is unhealthy, not because it's bad. It just doesn't fit anymore. If a leadership model doesn't match reality, let's have honest discussions and not get into a place of fear or panic. Let's just really look at what's next. What could be next?

Laurie Graham 30:53
You know, maybe the paid pastor is burning out because the workload is built for 200 people and you only have 35. Now the volunteer mass isn't there. So instead of managing volunteers, we're doing the work of way more volunteers than we could on any human level. Maybe your bi-vocational pastor is currently functioning like a full-time pastor with full-time hours, but doesn't have full-time hours to give. Like, look at what's really happening. Maybe the volunteer pastor is functioning like full-on clergy, without support or volunteer or validation or boundaries, and everyone's just being quiet, like pretending like everything is fine. Or maybe a lot of things have shifted over the past couple of decades, like attendance or energy or age or demographics or giving, but you're still trying to run your ministry like it's 1997 and here we are in 2025.

Laurie Graham 31:59
And remember, this doesn't mean anybody has failed. It just means the model might need a reset. Like, let's look at it. Changing the model doesn't mean defeat. It might be incredible wisdom, and it might free people and resources up in a way that completely changes the trajectory of your church in a great way. Churches thrive when leadership capacity matches real life. They really do. We can't be matching leadership capacity to wishful thinking.

Laurie Graham 32:36
Now, if you are looking at changing a model, it may feel scary at first. Like, I get it. Change is hard. It might feel scary for other people, and maybe it's exciting for you, but changing a model or considering it or looking at it can bring more clarity. It can bring more shared ownership, healthier boundaries, an environment that fits the people we have now instead of the people we wish we had. We really don't talk enough about this. We need to talk about it more. I think we don't talk about it enough because it feels vulnerable, but let's just embrace the reality that vulnerability honesty creates space for truth, and truth creates space for hope, breathing space.

Laurie Graham 33:32
So just keep in mind that the model is not the main issue. The silence around the model is. Clarity and vision and conversation. Honesty protects relationships. It keeps resentment out of your church culture. It makes each one of these models more sustainable, because then we can start naming hours and tasks and priorities and boundaries and limitations. Meditations. Each of these models can work beautifully, but let's not be scared of them, or let's not pretend. Let's face what's happening with hope and vision and utilize a model that works for what we have and where God is calling us to.

Laurie Graham 34:25
All right? So that's part two. We named real tensions behind leadership models, honoring the weight that pastors do carry, and untangling the difference between wanting stability and assuming that a church should run a certain model, because that's the way we've always done that. And hopefully we have separated a little bit out, you know, calling from capacity and just having the bigger, honest conversations throughout this whole finance series.

Laurie Graham 34:56
So next week, Part Three, we are stepping into the fun one, the question everybody whispers, but most people don't want to talk about, or maybe they do in a pretty negative way: "But why aren't people giving anymore?" The surprising thing is, the answer is wildly hopeful. So I hope you tune in next week.

Laurie Graham 35:17
If you find some hope and encouragement from our podcast, please go ahead and share them with others. There's a lot of small churches who haven't found us yet, who need the exact hope that you're finding, and please do go ahead and leave us a review. Give us some stars, give us some words below. It really helps other people find the podcast.

Keep going

Join 38,000+ people in small churches growing together, one email at a time.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.